There are like 10,000 Hamas members TOTAL so yah if you have 60,000 deaths then BASIC COMMON SENSE would tell you this is clearly a genocidal attack on civilians. I doubt the ratio is even 1:6 because they sure as fuck haven’t eliminated every Hamas member at this point.
Notably hamas being essentially the government there includes clerks cooks janitors, plumbers.
Kinda hard to personally blow up the building where bob the plumber sleeps killing him his kids and 10 other folks and claim to have hit any military targets.
Governments often claim to kill a military target when they kill a prime age male even without realistically identifying a combatant especially where bombing is used.
There are like 10,000 Hamas members TOTAL so yah if you have 60,000 deaths then BASIC COMMON SENSE would tell you this is clearly a genocidal attack on civilians. I doubt the ratio is even 1:6 because they sure as fuck haven’t eliminated every Hamas member at this point.
In the first 3 months they claimed to kill 9000 hamas fighters https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/israel-war-goals-unachieved-1.7087509
Hamas is closer to 40000 according to pre-war estimates.
Notably hamas being essentially the government there includes clerks cooks janitors, plumbers.
Kinda hard to personally blow up the building where bob the plumber sleeps killing him his kids and 10 other folks and claim to have hit any military targets.
Governments often claim to kill a military target when they kill a prime age male even without realistically identifying a combatant especially where bombing is used.
It’s probably closer to 80-90% civilians
Yeah likely 90%+ (90% is what you get when you assume a civilian man was killed for every civilian woman).
Estimated by whom?