Onno (VK6FLAB)

Anything and everything Amateur Radio and beyond. Heavily into Open Source and SDR, working on a multi band monitor and transmitter.

#geek #nerd #hamradio VK6FLAB #podcaster #australia #ITProfessional #voiceover #opentowork

  • 17 Posts
  • 274 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 4th, 2024

help-circle



  • I’m sorry, but no.

    Age validation is surveillance under the guise of “protecting the children”, which it spectacularly fails at for more reasons than I can count.

    1. Everyone has to validate their age, which creates a whole infrastructure that require documents that “prove” your age.
    2. A verified “under age” user will be added to a database by unscrupulous players, creating a honeypot for predators.
    3. Age verification isn’t universal, isn’t uniform and regardless of the jurisdiction in which it’s implemented, won’t actually prevent content from being procured from sources outside that jurisdiction.
    4. One source of objectionable content is another’s entertainment, legally so, given that laws are made in isolation from each other across borders.
    5. The result of such legislation is the effective censorship of content that some lawmaker finds objectionable, which will cause more harm than good.
    6. Operating System level age verification on open source platforms will spectacularly fail since they’re published outside the jurisdiction.

    So … no.


  • I understand your point and agree that this is the thin end of the wedge.

    What we’re doing here is discussing the phenomenon and I’m highlighting some concerns.

    I believe that this is how you get a dialogue happening which will effect change, which is what we’re both advocating.

    I think that age verification is about surveillance rather than protecting children and I think it should be fought at every level.

    This is me contributing to that fight.


  • In my opinion, storing a date is pretty much irrelevant unless there’s a process that validates the supplied date, otherwise every Linux user was born on 1/1/1, if not, an administrator can “fix” that

    Furthermore, that systemd thinks that it’s the place to store such information is in my opinion beyond absurd.

    Who appointed that project the source of age truth in the Linux ecosystem? What discussion was there, who was consulted and where was the vote?